Probabilistic Argumentation and Decision System

نویسندگان

  • Bernhard Anrig
  • Dalia Baziukaitė
چکیده

The concept of probabilistic argumentation systems PAS is restricted to two types of variables: assumptions, which model the uncertain part of the knowledge, and propositions, which model the rest of the information. Instantiations of PAS have been used for dealing with problems in different contexts. Here, we introduce a third kind of variables into PAS: so-called decision variables. This new kind allows to describe the decisions which a user can make to react on some state of the system. Consider that given a system state, the users can themselves set the values of some decision variables in order to guarantee the requirement. The interesting system states are now those for which the users can find at least one setting of “their” variables under which the requirement imposed on the system can be fulfilled. This can be seen as a game with two players, say nature against a user. Nature makes the first move and the user the second. If the requirement is fulfilled, the user wins (as the system is up), otherwise the user looses. Note that we do not include a concept of utility here as we are only interested in possible settings of decision variables. Further, we present an algorithm for computing arguments which exploits the special structure of PAS with decision variables. This allows now to use this framework for example in model-based reliability theory for computing structure functions.

برای دانلود رایگان متن کامل این مقاله و بیش از 32 میلیون مقاله دیگر ابتدا ثبت نام کنید

ثبت نام

اگر عضو سایت هستید لطفا وارد حساب کاربری خود شوید

منابع مشابه

Probabilistic Argumentation for Decision Making A Toolbox and Applications

Argumentation frameworks developed in AI have greatly eased the developments of many kinds of intelligent systems. Recently, to deal with quantitative uncertainties, several authors integrate probabilities into such frameworks to propose probabilistic argumentation frameworks. However, the developments of intelligent systems using these new frameworks are still hindered by the lack of programmi...

متن کامل

Probabilistic Argumentation Systems with Decision Variables

The general concept of probabilistic argumentation systems PAS is restricted to the two types of variables: assumptions, which model the uncertain part of the knowledge, and propositions, which model the rest of the information. Here, we introduce a third kind into PAS: so-called decision variables. This new kind allows to describe the decisions a user can make to react on some state of the sys...

متن کامل

Finding a Probabilistic Approach to Develop a Fuzzy Expert System for the Assessment of Research Projects using ANP Approach

Nowadays, project selection is a vital decision in many organizations. Because competition among research projects in order to gain more budgets and to attain new scientific domain has increased. Due to multiple objectives and budgeting restrictions for academic research projects have led to the use of expert system for decision making by academic and research centers. The existing methods suff...

متن کامل

Argumentation and Risk Assessment

Over the last ten years we have been involved in the development of a formal framework for decision making and reasoning under uncertainty based on "argumentation". The latter provides a way of managing uncertainty which differs from probabilistic inference and is particularly valuable in those many practical situations where uncertainty cannot be quantified. Recently we have been applying argu...

متن کامل

Probabilistic Argumentation. An Equational Approach

There is a generic way to add any new feature to a system. It involves 1) identifying the basic units which build up the system and 2) introducing the new feature to each of these basic units. In the case where the system is argumentation and the feature is probabilistic we have the following. The basic units are: a. the nature of the arguments involved; b. the membership relation in the set S ...

متن کامل

Imprecise Probability in Graphical Models: Achievements and Challenges

Knowledge-based operations for graphical models in planning p. 3 Some representation and computational issues in social choice p. 15 Nonlinear deterministic relationships in Bayesian networks p. 27 Penniless propagation with mixtures of truncated exponentials p. 39 Approximate factorisation of probability trees p. 51 Abductive inference in Bayesian networks : finding a partition of the explanat...

متن کامل

ذخیره در منابع من


  با ذخیره ی این منبع در منابع من، دسترسی به آن را برای استفاده های بعدی آسان تر کنید

عنوان ژورنال:

دوره   شماره 

صفحات  -

تاریخ انتشار 2002